The Bachelor's Ali Fedotowsky and Catherine Giudici Share Their Radically Different Approaches to Pregnancy

Good friends Ali Fedotowsky and Catherine Giudici, former contestants on The Bachelor, are due a week apart. But that's where the similarities end!

Ali Fedotowsky & Catherine Lowe Play Hot or Not: Maternity Fashion Edition

Fit Pregnancy & Baby June 2016 Cover Cheyenne Ellis
Ali Fedotowsky and Catherine Giudici first met at a press event for ABC's The Bachelor and hit it off immediately. "I felt a connection to Ali," Giudici says. Though they now live some 1,400 miles apart—Fedotowsky in Los Angeles and Giudici in Dallas—they text each other all the time. Lately the threads have centered around their ever-growing bellies. Giudici and her husband, Sean Lowe, who proposed to her on the Season 17 finale, are expecting their first baby on July 5; Fedotowsky (who also starred in The Bachelorette) and her radio-host fiancé, Kevin Manno, are expecting on July 13. Yet for all that these friends have in common, their feelings about pregnancy and parenthood could not be more different. Listen in!

Related: The Latest Celebrity Pregnancy Announcements

How are you feeling? 

ALI FEDOTOWSKY I've been tired, and I was so nauseated during my first trimester that I lost 8 pounds. I only ate rice, toast, bagels with cream cheese, and clementines.

CATHERINE GIUDICI I've been really blessed to have no symptoms. I forget all the time that I'm pregnant, except for the fact that there's a belly in my way.

Were you trying to get pregnant? 

AF Yes! And I thought it'd happen right away, since I'd spent my whole life trying not to get pregnant. After two months of trying, I had a chemical pregnancy [a very early miscarriage], which was a huge disappointment. Afterward, I just wanted a baby so badly—nothing about that time was romantic. When I finally got a positive result, I jumped around the house, listening to Justin Bieber's "Baby."

CG We weren't really trying. One day I felt a little sick, so I asked Sean to pick up a pregnancy test. Whenever I feel weird, I take one—and they're always negative. After I peed on the stick, I climbed into bed without even checking it. Sean asked if he could. When he walked out of the bathroom, he said, "Baby, it's negative," and I was like, "Yeah, I thought so." Then he said, "And by negative, I mean positive." I had to look at the test myself, because I'd never seen a positive before. Then we both looked at each other and had no idea what to do or say. Finally, I said, "Want to watch TV?" We sat in bed in silence for the rest of the night, watching Family Guy. Inside, I was thinking, Oh, crap, we've got to be adults now.

Ali Fedotowsky Wearing Green Army Jacket Cheyenne Ellis

How do you feel about your body? 

AF While it's crazy to get on the scale and see your number so high, I'm all about my growing belly. I feel sexier now than ever before, partly because Kevin writes me notes every single week about how beautiful I am.

CG As much as I know I deserve some grace, I feel like my boobs are out of control. I didn't buy maternity clothes until 24 weeks along because I was trying to fit into my usual stuff, which wasn't working. 

How's the sex? 

AF I don't want to have sex at all. Mentally, I can't get past the fact that something so adult is happening in the presence of my little baby. Kevin feels the same way. I mean, we'll be intimate once in a while, but it's not the same. All I think about is the baby. And when I was sick during the first trimester, I was like, "Get the hell away from me. If you come near me with that thing, I will strangle you!" 

CG I've always wanted sex with my husband, and that's not changed one bit. I'm grateful Sean isn't scared to do it with me, and he tries to be gentle. We're obviously not doing crazy stuff, but you can still do the same stuff you were doing before. 

Do you feel ready to be a mom? 

AF I'm ready to have a baby, but I'm also aware that I have no idea what that entails. I know I'm going to cry: tears of joy and of frustration from sleeplessness. Whenever I have a holy-crap moment, Kevin calms me down. He says, "We're so ready. I want the baby here today." 

CG There's not one ounce of me that's ready. We haven't done a single thing to prepare for the fact that we're bringing a new human into our house and lives. Instead, we're relishing our time together and doing whatever we want while we still can, like taking naps and bingeing on Netflix.

Boy or girl? 

AF Girl! Kevin and I are both high-anxiety planners, so we had to know. I had a blood test at 10 weeks, and I called the office every day afterward to see if the results came in. They were so annoyed with me. Once we got the envelope from the doctor, we drove it home and videotaped ourselves opening it. 

CG We're not finding out, because we just want a healthy baby. It doesn't matter what it is, but we're both convinced it's a boy. 

Catherine Giudici Wearing Blue Dress Cheyenne Ellis

Are you taking baby classes? 

AF We signed up for classes, including breastfeeding and infant care. But we're not taking a childbirth class, because I don't want to know about it. I don't want to see videos. Labor never happens the way you think it will anyway. 

CG No, I haven't signed up for anything, but I might take a Lamaze childbirth class.

Drugs during labor? 

AF I'm scared of pushing a baby through my vagina, so yes, I want the epidural as soon as possible. 

CG My plan is no drugs. But I'm not against it. If I need something, I'll have a safe word to tell Sean. 

Will you document the birth? 

AF I'm having a birth photographer in the labor and delivery room. 

CG We plan to just take pictures with Sean's phone. 

Do you want a big family? 

AF You never know how you'll feel or how you'll be as a parent. After this baby, maybe I'll be like, "I can't wait to have another," or maybe I'll love this baby so much that I'll only want to have this one. 

CG Well, if it goes this easily, I could have five! My plan was always to have three and adopt two. 

What was it like being photographed together? 

AF Super fun. Our due dates are so close, our pregnant tummies look exactly the same. 

CG No. Ali's carrying so much cuter than me. She's taller than me. 

AF Catherine, you're nuts. You're the cutest pregnant person ever. 

Related: The Hottest Celebrity Bikini Bumps